Dentharr needs a refined earth
Sinaefay needs a refined spirit of air, and an exquisite spirit of water.
Beldras needs (need to check)

The Kender don’t needs anything.
Flavia don’t needs anything.
Gildana don’t need anything.
Mill needs ( need to check )
Laria needs a refined air.
Tenalafel needs ( need to check )

I’ll look at what Alchemical weapons I have stored in bank too.

Also I have the following Alchemical blank in bank :
– Greatsword
– Shortbow
– Morningstar
– Heavy Shield
– Scepter

Edited to add the relevant information

Unfortunately only my CLR is flagged so would need to also flag FTR and WIZ (actually all my characters hehe). CLR has some ingredients but I am not sure which since I only played the raid 4 times a very long time ago.

I am not sure if I understand this particular crafting or if I am after the correct effects, so please let me know if something is usually more appropriate:

For melee I would do an Alchemical Greataxe with Material Flametouched plus the following martial effects T1 Earth (lots of CC coupled with the Rock Boots I usualy use at L20!), T2 Earth (reliable DPS from acid+disintegration that works on most) and T3 either Earth or Water (Will saves might be better nowadays for mobs at L20 considering evasive drows?). Advices?

Maybe I would also do a second Alchemical with T1+2 Air for the Stunning +10 and Doublestrike 6%, but so far I had mixed feelings about stuns in epics unless I go specifically for them (all the bonuses possible and max STR). LS is half-damage for drows most of the time I believe. Is this a useless combination except for wind stance monks?

For wizard Crystal Scepter with T1+2 Water and T3 Fire plus maybe another with Byeshk T1+2 Fire and T3 Air as some sort of pre-Twilight combination. Suggestions?

Thank you Wish for the feedback! 🙂

I believe that no one will use alchemical weaponry except in the L20-22 window since at L23 you have the CitW weaponry which is far better. For caster the sticks would merely help consolidate some things in a single slot since everything they have to offer can be fit somewhere else for sure and again Twilight is just too good to pass up.

I used Rock Boots in lower eH like Carnival chain going in solo and they did proced a couple of times which is satisfactory for me considering L20 is not the cap anymore. The guards on them are 2 by the way: Stone Prison Guard – 50% chance – fortitude DC17 with a recurring save every 25 seconds (high chance for them to roll a 1 which means they will be held for 25″) and also a Earth Grab Guard – 4% chance – reflex DC35 duration 6″ no save (fairly decent I would say).

Of course that later once I hit L23 (you could start using GH eN items at this point) I don’t expect them to fill any role, but this is why they are at T2 (BtA) so can go to another character to help during levelling. Well, this is part of my thinking process to use during levelling as much BtA gear as possible and have BtC only where it matters at cap 😀

What combination of weapons are you doing for your melees btw?

Vyra’s ‘Pesh atm is Flametouched iron with the first tier of earth, decided on having T” as air for doublestrike and lightning strike to help build hate a little, and T3 as air becasue that is a damage type that little has resistance to.

I dont particularly want to start other alchemical weps on other chars due to the large grind for spirits but as the arti is sitting on an exqusite air and I want an excuse to have her hold a cannith style repeater, but that is not melee 🙂

Have not looked at giving other melees weps since they were endgame shinys so a little iffy. For chars that do 2WF something like Fire/Fire/air and earth/earth/air are combos I have down from old equip plans. The first combo for seeker, bypassing good DR and the +2 Str The seccond for CC, the extra few hp, disint proc(No Save) and resonable DPS .

For a 2hander im not quite as sure. Possibly first tier earth would not be as usefull as fewer attacks than 2WF. Flametouched Fire/Water/Air would be a reasonable boss beater: seeker and the two DoT procs from Water T2 which I hear good things about.

~Wish

Awesome Wishie! I love the brainstorming 🙂

I actually thought in the beginning that max DPS is probably Flametouched Fire/Air/Air, but then Fire is not such a good element overall and while seeker +10 is definitively sweet it is only +4 vs the Ring of the Stalker who also has some other nice things on it.

So I went ahead and for T1 decided it is a toss between Air and Earth. For a monk I would have went Air for sure, but since I don’t find my stuns reliable I decided Earth would fit me best.

Now for T2 is very tricky since of course I would have preffered Air for LS and Doublestrike (at L20 I use Spare Hand which has 3% doublestrike but that is half of Alchemical), Fire for the added STR (Righteous not really needed because of Flametouched and Incineration is rather weak) or maybe more CON from Earth, but then you come and suggest Water. Of course it has some excellent DoTs so very good point.

At T3 I went for Water (Will save) since the other AoEs are Reflex or Fortitude saves which I believe will be saved pretty often in melee range.

In the end to spice things up I will do:
Catgrim (CLR – flagged!) – Flametouched Earth/Water/Water
Catpaw (FTR – not flagged yet!) – Flametouched Air/Air/Air
Catrush (ART – not flagged yet!) – Flametouched Earth/Air/Water
Catgrin (WIZ – not flagged yet!) – not flagged yet! – I have no idea since Wishie kind of turned my mood down hehe hope more would post ideas

@Wishie Why do you say they are a grind? I was under the impression that if we pass around the spirits as needed we could actually do some weapons pretty fast. Spirits have a 50% drop chance for each player right? Of course luck is a factor 🙂

Now we also have to run MA or something since I don’t have any alchemical weapons except on my ART 😀 Plus I have to check what spirits I already have on my CLR. Might as well make a different combination to speed things up a bit.